Are Microsoft's Copilot+ PCs a Worthy Rival to Apple Silicon?

AI-created, human-edited.

In the latest episode of MacBreak Weekly, Leo Laporte, Andy Ihnatko, Jason Snell, and guest Mikah Sargent discussed Microsoft's newly announced Copilot+ PCs, powered by Qualcomm's Snapdragon Elite X chips with integrated AI processing capabilities. The panelists weighed in on whether this move represents an actual watershed moment for Windows in the AI arena and if it can legitimately rival Apple's trailblazing M-series chips.

The crux of the debate centered on Microsoft's apparent overnight pivot to positioning AI as the centerpiece of its hardware strategy. Mikah Sargent expressed amazement at how swiftly the company has reoriented itself around AI, branding its new machines as "Copilot+ PCs" and even dedicating a physical key for AI functionality.

Andy Ihnatko questioned the practicality of such a committed AI focus, suggesting it might prematurely date the devices. "Is that the tool that people are going to want to use for that kind of task?" he pondered, drawing parallels to ill-fated dedicated hardware buttons of the past.

However, Jason Snell countered that Microsoft's response could be viewed as the most robust counterattack yet to Apple's industry-shaking transition to Apple Silicon. He highlighted the potential appeal to Windows users seeking an experience akin to the performance and battery life gains Mac users have enjoyed.

The panel delved into the technical specifics, analyzing Qualcomm's claims of up to 40 TOPS (trillion operations per second) of AI performance on the new chips. There was also scrutiny around Microsoft's touted "recall" feature, which periodically captures screen activity to aid in retrieving past work.

While impressed by Microsoft's agility, concerns about the potential privacy implications of such comprehensive logging were raised. The specter of enterprise compliance requirements and data handling policies also loomed large.

Ultimately, the hosts agreed that Microsoft's Copilot+ PCs represent an ambitious – if somewhat premature – gambit to maintain relevance in an AI-driven future. However, whether Windows can genuinely challenge Apple's Silicon dominance remains an open question that is contingent on real-world performance and a robust software ecosystem to leverage the new hardware's AI muscle.

Become a subscriber and never miss an episode: MacBreak Weekly