Dangling Domains and Digital Deception: Inside Microsoft's Accidental Honeypot

AI-created, human-edited.

In a recent episode of Security Now, hosts Steve Gibson and Leo Laporte delved into a fascinating story that underscores both the complexities and ingenuities within the world of cybersecurity. The tale revolves around code.microsoft.com, a domain that transitioned from hosting Visual Studio Code documentation to becoming an unintentional, then intentional, honeypot for Microsoft's cybersecurity team.

The saga began when code.microsoft.com, once an active site for developer resources, was decommissioned around 2021. What should have been a routine retirement of a subdomain led to an alarming discovery: the domain had briefly fallen into the hands of malicious actors who repurposed it for a malware command and control service. This incident highlighted a concerning vulnerability that Steve Gibson found "nothing short of insane" – the ability for someone outside Microsoft to commandeer a subdomain of microsoft.com by simply giving their own Azure cloud instance the same name.

Gibson expressed disbelief at this architectural flaw, stating, "All I can surmise is that there must be some serious design problems over in Microsoft land for that to ever have been possible." The hosts pondered the implications of such a vulnerability, particularly for enterprises that might whitelist entire Microsoft networks, inadvertently granting trust to what could be a compromised subdomain.

However, the story takes an intriguing turn. Rather than simply shutting down the compromised subdomain, Microsoft's security team saw an opportunity. They repurposed code.microsoft.com into a honeypot – a decoy system designed to attract and monitor malicious activity. This decision transformed a potential security nightmare into a valuable source of threat intelligence.

The sophistication of Microsoft's honeypot impressed even the technically savvy Gibson. He highlighted the system's ability to simulate over 300 known vulnerabilities while maintaining control that actual exploits would typically bypass. "So it looks like a duck and it quacks like a duck, but it ain't no duck. Very, very cool tech," Gibson remarked.

This honeypot became a crucial tool for Microsoft, providing insights into emerging threats, zero-day vulnerabilities, and the tactics of various threat actors. It played a pivotal role during major security events like the Log4Shell incident and the Exchange ProxyLogon vulnerability, enabling Microsoft to track exploit developments and better protect its customers.

The hosts also discussed the eventual "outing" of the honeypot. Despite efforts to keep it under wraps, including closing bug bounty reports with a wink and a nod, the secret eventually leaked. A sudden spike in traffic and social media buzz in April 2023 marked the end of code.microsoft.com's covert operations. In a three-hour period, the subdomain faced nearly 80,000 exploits targeting a WeChat vulnerability, signaling that the jig was up.

Gibson and Laporte marveled at the difficulty of keeping secrets on the internet, speculating on how the exploit URL might have ended up indexed by Google. "It's easy to imagine that Google would have set up Chrome to feed URLs back to them for bot crawling indexing," Gibson suggested.

The podcast segment concluded with reflections on the broader implications of this story. It reveals the double-edged nature of the internet's interconnectedness – the same mechanisms that can expose vulnerabilities can also be harnessed for defense. Moreover, it hints at the depth of talent within large tech organizations like Microsoft, often overshadowed by public-facing mishaps.

"Why don't we get the sense in general that Microsoft is this good?" Gibson pondered, suggesting that brilliant minds might be "buried so deeply down in the infrastructure that you just talk to morons on the surface." Laporte offered a different take, attributing issues more to the sheer complexity of such large systems where "things fall through the cracks."

This captivating discussion on Security Now not only sheds light on an innovative application of honeypot technology but also prompts broader questions about cybersecurity practices, the challenges of maintaining vast digital infrastructures, and the hidden ingenuity within tech giants. As we navigate an increasingly complex digital landscape, stories like that of code.microsoft.com remind us that in the world of cybersecurity, vulnerabilities and victories often emerge from the most unexpected places. 

Subscribe so you don't miss an episode: Security Now