Is Social Media Addiction Real?

AI-generated, human-reviewed.

On This Week in Tech, panelists dissect the high-profile Los Angeles lawsuit against Meta, TikTok, and YouTube, raising a critical question: Is social media genuinely addictive, or are we misunderstanding its impact on our lives and kids’ well-being?

Why Is Social Media Under Legal Fire?

Social media platforms—including Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube—are being sued for allegedly designing their products to deliberately addict and harm young users. The case, compared in media coverage to the historic tobacco lawsuits, could fundamentally change how these companies run their services and interact with millions of users.

According to Leo Laporte and expert guests on This Week in Tech, the trial’s outcome may set major precedents for tech accountability, digital health, and user protections. Prior lawsuits have focused on privacy or monopoly power, but this one directly accuses social media giants of targeting kids, amplifying harmful content, and creating habit-forming algorithms.

How Do Social Media Algorithms Influence Users?

Most popular platforms use algorithms (automated systems that curate, recommend, and promote content) designed to keep users engaged. These algorithms optimize for metrics like “time on site” and “engagement,” which often mean pushing the most captivating, controversial, or emotionally charged material.

As Gary Rivlin highlighted, internal company documents from Meta show designers were aware that “teens can't switch off from Instagram even if they want to,” and that content promoting eating disorders and body image anxiety was widespread. The panel discussed how platforms knowingly fine-tune their systems to maximize attention, sometimes at users’ expense.

Key point: The lawsuit uses these admissions to argue that social media addiction is not just about lack of personal discipline, but about corporate manipulation.

Addiction or Habit? What Does Science Say?

One major debate is whether excessive social media use is “addiction” in the clinical sense, like drug or gambling dependency, or simply a strong habit driven by design. Victoria Song emphasized that the constant notifications, infinite scroll, and tailored recommendations trigger dopamine release, which can make the experience compulsive, especially for teenagers.

Yet, as discussed on the show, the term “addiction” is medically controversial when it comes to social media. Unlike chemicals, digital platforms don’t create physical dependence, but they do shape behaviors and can lead to anxiety, depression, and even radicalization in certain cases.

What Can Parents and Users Do?

Panelists agreed that young people are uniquely vulnerable due to developing brains and heightened sensitivity to peer feedback. Countries like Australia and France are moving to ban social media for minors or to enforce stronger boundaries, such as restricted phone use in schools.

Listeners were encouraged to:

• Set boundaries for device and app usage at home
• Use features to limit algorithmic recommendations and opt for chronological feeds when possible
• Discuss critical thinking and media literacy skills with children
• Recognize both the positives (community, support, education) and negatives (commercialization, misinformation) of social platforms

The Whole Scroll

• A landmark LA lawsuit accuses social media giants of deliberately addicting teens and promoting harmful content
• Internal memos reveal platforms understood—and in some cases exploited—user vulnerabilities
• Most experts agree that algorithms drive compulsive use, especially among minors
• The difference between addiction and habit is debated, but digital harms are real
• Parents, educators, and governments are taking steps to protect kids, including bans and screen restrictions
• Future court decisions may reshape the social media landscape for everyone

This lawsuit against Meta, TikTok, and YouTube could be a turning point for how social media is designed, regulated, and experienced. Whether you’re worried about your own screen time or your children’s safety online, the case highlights urgent questions about corporate responsibility, algorithmic power, and digital well-being. Stay informed, as changes may be coming soon to the platforms many depend on daily.

To hear this full conversation and stay updated every week, subscribe to This Week in Tech: https://twit.tv/shows/this-week-in-tech/episodes/1069